Science Into Practice - Better control of Scaptomyza

In the UK in 2009, Scaptomyza flava was identified as the pest responsible for the economic damage on watercress and Cruciferae grown as baby-leaf salads.

Up to 40 per cent of leaves were damaged and growers incurred financial loss from additional pesticide applications, crop rejections and increased packhouse costs.

In AHDB Horticulture project FV 376, crop covers were shown to be effective. Two experimental products and spinosad (Tracer) were identified as effective controls in leaf dip laboratory tests in project FV 408 and project FV 408a, led by Gemma Hough of ADAS, aimed to identify insecticides that are effective against S. flava.

In FV 408a adult Scaptomyza spp. were collected from a commercial crop, which made it impossible to confirm that each adult was S. flava. The work was therefore carried out on "Scaptomyza spp.". First, the pests' survival on pesticide-treated rocket leaves was assessed in the lab. There were 11 treatments including approved and coded products. Tracer, HDCI 060, HDCI 045 and HDCI 047 were the best performers. Next, the pests' survival and leaf puncturing damage on whole rocket plants sprayed with the four treatments was determined.

All treatments significantly reduced numbers of live adults, leaf punctures and leaf mines per plant compared with the untreated control. The last trial was on a commercial baby-leaf cruciferous crop. Treatments included the four best pesticides, an untreated control and a fleeced treatment.

All significantly reduced the mean number of leaf punctures per plant compared to the control. Fleece was the most effective treatment, followed by HDCI 060 and HDCI 045. But all, including the least effective, were as good as Tracer. Discussions to obtain extensions of authorisation for minor use (EAMUs) for the best-performing products is ongoing.

AHDB Horticulture

For details on all AHDB Horticulture activity, see


Did you find this article useful? Why not subscribe to the magazine? Please call 08451 55 73 55 for more information or visit

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Sign up now
Already registered?
Sign in

Read These Next

Crop protection: edibles armoury

Crop protection: edibles armoury

New products are still coming through despite challenging regulations. Gavin McEwan reports on what's new for growers of edible crops.

Crop protection: Ornamentals armoury

Crop protection: Ornamentals armoury

What can ornamental plant growers do to meet increasing pressure from the industry and consumers to become more sustainable? Sally Drury investigates the available product options.

Weed control: effective management

Weed control: effective management

Control is needed in urban areas as well as on sports turf and nursery sites. Sally Drury looks at the best ways to manage weeds as well as costs.