Producer organisation mergers pressed to improve efficiency and bargaining power

British producer organisations should collaborate or merge to gain economies of scale and a stronger position in the market, European Food & Farming Partnerships (EFFP) partner Duncan Rawson has urged.

Evolving markets require greater producer expertise - image: Kai Hendry
Evolving markets require greater producer expertise - image: Kai Hendry

Addressing an audience of producer representatives last week, he said: "British producer organisations are relatively small by north European standards. The industry needs to be consolidating to compete more effectively and improve its bargaining position when it supplies large and demanding customers."

These customers are themselves evolving, he pointed out. "Tesco in particular is under a lot of pressure and that will lead to price aggression, while Asda's buyout of IPL has cut out the middle man, and Morrisons is driving direct supply too."

Larger supplier groups would be able to employ the expertise needed to handle these high-volume deals, Rawson argued.

"It also enables you to add value through investment in infrastructure, research and development, and improved branding and marketing. You can drive supply chain efficiency and even access new markets," he added.

EFFP regional manager Liz Bowles said producer organisations could gain advantages of scale through a range of business models - from joint ventures to umbrella associations - to complete mergers or acquisitions, which offer greater potential to realise synergies.

Offering a wider European view, Gaston Opdekamp, managing director of Belgian producer organisation Hoogstraten, said collaboration across national borders can also bring benefits to both parties.

Hoogstraten has successfully collaborated with Dutch strawberry supplier CLTV Zundert and another Belgian supplier to form In-Co, an association of producer organisations.

This raises the level of EU support from 50 to 60 per cent and could even be more in future, Opdekamp explained. "We are pushing for this. Crisis management in particular has to managed at a European level."

He added: "When I visit shops in England, I see 'buy British' everywhere. It's not like that in Belgium. Yet our relationships with retailers are much easier. They have high ethical standards."

Producer view - Sector scale needed

Seven-member Fruit Growers Alliance director James Smith acknowledged that his organisation needs scale to become better resourced.

"I have my own business, so my time is limited," he said. "But growers in other producer organisations aren't available to us, and there are not too many independent growers. They are also likely to be PO-shy - they may think we are too expensive or controlling.

"We have had talks with most other top fruit organisations. The sector needs to be much less fragmented and the multiples want fewer suppliers. It's growers who are reluctant to collaborate - they need to understand its benefits."


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Sign up now
Already registered?
Sign in

Read These Next

What do the latest growers' trials show on how to improve soil health?

What do the latest growers' trials show on how to improve soil health?

A recent Innovative Farmers conference heard how the network's programme of on-farm trials, or "Field Labs", involving around 1,000 farmers and growers is seeking usable practical findings that can be applied across farming.

Is leaving the EU an opportunity to harness the potential of agri-tech?

Is leaving the EU an opportunity to harness the potential of agri-tech?

A group of leading industry and research figures has agreed a series of agri-tech measures that will be recommended to Government as a means of making British farming more profitable and productive post-Brexit.

What do fruit and vegetable growers hope for from a renationalised farming policy?

What do fruit and vegetable growers hope for from a renationalised farming policy?

Defra's "Health & Harmony" consultation paper, which closed for responses this week, has given growers and their representative bodies a chance to shape the largest reformulation of farming and land-use policy in nearly half a century.


Follow us on:
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Google +

Horticulture Week Top UK FRUIT PRODUCERS

See our exclusive ranking of fruit producers by annual turnover. 

Horticulture Jobs
More Horticulture Jobs

Pest & Disease Tracker bulletin 

The latest pest and disease alerts, how to treat them, plus EAMU updates, sent direct to your inbox.

Sign up here

Professor Geoffrey Dixon

GreenGene International chair Geoff Dixon on the business of fresh produce production
 

Read Professor Geoffrey Dixon