Industry slams EU amenity pesticide restrictions for being 'unscientific'

Unduly restrictive measures on the amenity use of pesticides proposed by the European Parliament are not based on scientific fact, delegates at last week's Amenity Forum conference were told.

The UK government is not prepared to support the pesticides legislation being hammered out in the EU this autumn, said parliamentary under-secretary in the Department for Work & Pensions Lord Bill McKenzie. Lord McKenzie joined experts at the conference on weed control on 2 October to debate the future of the sector.

"Unfortunately, the negotiations in Brussels have not proceeded as we would have wished," said Lord McKenzie, who has responsibility for the Health & Safety Executive.

"We are unable to support the text. However, we do hope that suitable amendments will be made as the negotiations continue this autumn."

The legislation comes under the overarching EU Thematic Strategy for Pesticides. It includes a proposed regulation to replace the Pesticide Authorisation Directive 91/414/EEC, as well as a proposed new Sustainable Use Directive that could severely restrict or prohibit use of pesticides in sensitive areas such as around schools and hospitals.

The head of the Pesticides Safety Directorate's environment policy branch, Adrian Dixon, said the no-spray zones were proving a particular point of contention.

"Member states say this is not scientifically based and want it to be down to science, not politics. "This is one where we firmly say 'What is the science behind it?'

"The UK is still lobbying hard and trying to defeat the thing on logic and science but when you are in higher-level political discussions other things hold sway."

Lord McKenzie said the Government would not support the substantial no-spray zones set out in the Sustainable Use Directive.

He said: "On a number of fronts we think the approach of the EU is unduly restrictive and not based on science. Decisions have to be based on facts and evidence. We will not recommend the adoption of such measures and will do all we can to influence the debate."

Network Rail's senior lineside engineer Dr Neil Strong is heavily involved with vegetation management and said the organisation was lobbying MEPs, as well as MPs.

He added: "No one has the workforce to do all manual clearance - we can do the work but not without the use of herbicides."


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Sign up now
Already registered?
Sign in

Read These Next

What's new in amenity sector weed control?

What's new in amenity sector weed control?

The latest training, new products and hardware can help amenity managers with weed control, says Sally Drury.

Get set for this summer's Parks & Gardens Live 2019

Get set for this summer's Parks & Gardens Live 2019

Product showcase, kit demos, expert workshops and careers advice all on the schedule.

How are employers in horticulture developing their offer to staff?

How are employers in horticulture developing their offer to staff?

Thanks to a skills shortage in horticulture, employers are working hard to enhance their offer to new recruits -- from training to profit-share schemes. Rachel Anderson reports on developments at six firms in very different branches of the industry.


Follow us on:
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Google +

HORTICULTURE WEEK Custodian Awards

The Horticulture Week Custodian Awards are open to all professionals responsible for the management and development of parks, gardens and other green spaces. Find out more about how and why you should enter the 2019 Custodian Awards.

Horticulture Jobs
More Horticulture Jobs

Products & Kit Resources

HORTICULTURE WEEK Custodian Awards

Find out more about the outstanding parks, gardens and arboricultural projects and teams that became our Custodian Award 2018 winners.